The dust has barely settled from Joe Tate’s audacious kidney heist, yet Emmerdale fans are already speculating on his inevitable downfall. Following Monday’s episode, which detailed Joe’s escape plans after orchestrating Caleb Milligan’s stabbing and kidney theft, a wave of theories has flooded Reddit and social media.

Let’s recap: Joe, now armed with Caleb’s stolen kidney and suffering from chronic kidney disease, announced his departure for Dubai. He informed Dr. Crowley, his personal medic, of his intentions to leave the village, particularly after his messy affair with Dawn Fletcher. As the episode closed, Joe was seen heading to the airport, coldly deleting Dawn’s contact from his phone. Meanwhile, Caleb remains completely unaware that Joe was the mastermind behind his near-fatal stabbing and organ theft.

However, fans are convinced this is far from the end of Joe Tate. They predict a dramatic “Who attacked Joe?” storyline, a revenge-fueled mystery that will grip the village. One Reddit user articulated the sentiment perfectly: “When everything is revealed about what Joe has done—drugging Noah, the limo crash, the affair with Dawn, deceiving Manpreet, arranging an attack on Caleb, and taking his kidney without his knowledge—I wonder if there could be a ‘Who attacked Joe?’ storyline.”

The user further elaborated on the potential suspects, creating a veritable rogues’ gallery of those Joe has wronged. “There’s so many people it could be if there was an attack that left him unconscious in hospital. All the different groups of people he has affected: Charity, Ross, and Noah for drugging Noah and the limo crash; Jacob (possibility); Matty, Carrie, Cain (would be a suspect, but it wouldn’t be him); Vanessa, Mary, Tracy (it would have made more sense if Tracy was given Manpreet’s story; she’d have more reason to get back at Joe for her sister and herself); the Home Farm group; Billy for the affair, maybe Dawn if her marriage falls apart and Joe discards her; Kim for finding out what he was doing while he was living there; Manpreet; the Milligans when they find out Joe arranged the stabbing and took Caleb’s kidney; Caleb would love to get him back; Ruby as protective of her family (knocked Ethan down and finished her dad off); Steph as she doesn’t want to lose her dad. All could be likely; Cain and Chas too for their brother. Not sure if Cain and Caleb still hate each other or if they’ve made up.”

The sheer number of potential attackers has fans buzzing, envisioning a scenario where Joe is left hospitalized, leaving the village to unravel the mystery. The list of suspects is a testament to Joe’s trail of destruction, a litany of betrayals and manipulations that have left a wake of hurt and anger.

Viewers are in agreement: Joe’s comeuppance is inevitable, and it will be spectacular. The sheer scope of his crimes—from drugging Noah and orchestrating the limo crash to his callous affair with Dawn and the shocking kidney theft—has created a long list of enemies.

Charity, Ross, and Noah have ample reason to seek revenge for Joe’s manipulation and the chaos he caused. The Milligans, particularly Caleb, will be driven by a thirst for retribution once they learn the truth about the kidney theft. Even Kim, who initially welcomed Joe, might turn against him after discovering his deceitful actions.

The possibility of Dawn, Billy, and Manpreet seeking vengeance adds layers of complexity to the potential “Whodunnit.” The betrayal and heartbreak Joe inflicted on their relationships could fuel a desperate desire for payback.

And let’s not forget Ruby and Steph, fiercely protective of their family. Their potential involvement adds a dark, unpredictable element to the unfolding drama.

The Reddit user’s theory has sparked a frenzy of speculation, with fans eager to see Joe face the consequences of his actions. The village is poised for a dramatic showdown, a clash of vengeance and retribution that will leave viewers on the edge of their seats.

Emmerdale is about to plunge into a thrilling mystery, a “Whodunnit” that will test loyalties and expose the darkest corners of the village. Joe Tate’s arrogance has created a storm of enemies, and his downfall is imminent. Prepare for a rollercoaster of suspicion, betrayal, and revenge. This is Emmerdale, and the reckoning is coming.