I’m Disappointed Yellowstone Is Giving Spinoffs to Everyone Except the 1 Character Who Deserves It the Most

Jacob (Harrison Ford) and Cara (Helen Mirren) Dutton appear in 1923 Season 2
Image by Morena Perez Vitale
Quick Links
Yellowstone Is Giving a Lot of Characters Spinoffs

Cara Dutton Deserves Her Own Spinoff

What Would Cara Dutton’s Spinoff Look Like?

The Yellowstone franchise is about to enter a new era as several main shows in the television universe come to an end. The flagship series concluded late last year, culminating with an early series finale following Kevin Costner’s early exit. Now, 1923 has also come to an end, featuring the Duttons’ final fight against the villainous Donald Whitfield. Even with two series down for the count, Taylor Sheridan’s neo-Western franchise is far from finished.

With Yellowstone and 1923 finished, Sheridan and his team have new stories up their sleeves. Plenty of Yellowstone spinoffs are on the way, following several characters from previous series as well as all-new ones whom audiences haven’t met before. As exciting as each of these spinoffs is, Sheridan is missing one extremely compelling possibility for a new Yellowstone series starring one of the franchise’s most interesting characters.

Beth Dutton ponders her next move on the porch of her father’s house with a shotgun on her lap in Yellowstone.
Related

Beth Dutton ponders her next move on the porch of her father's house with a shotgun on her lap in Yellowstone.

This 1 Beth Dutton Line Has Me Even More Excited About the Next Yellowstone Spinoff
Beth Dutton and Rip Wheeler are set to return in their own spinoff series–and I’m excited to see how it expands on this line from Yellowstone.

Yellowstone Is Giving a Lot of Characters Spinoffs
Taylor Sheridan’s Television Universe Is Continuing in Multiple New Spinoffs
Spencer Dutton sitting in a tent, wearing a brown vest over a beige shirt and a brown hat, in 1923.
Upcoming Yellowstone Spinoffs

Untitled Rip & Beth Spinoff

1944

The Madison

Untitled Kayce Spinoff

6666

read more

Michelle Pfeiffer in front of a logo for Yellowstone
Related

Everything We Know About Yellowstone’s The Madison Spinoff
The Madison is an upcoming spinoff to Taylor Sheridan’s hit Yellowstone series. Here’s everything we know about the upcoming series.

Cara Dutton Deserves Her Own Spinoff
1923’s Best Character Needs to Return
Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren) sitting with a gun on her lap outside in 1923

Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren) sitting with a gun on her lap outside in 1923
Image via Paramount
1923 Cast & Character Guide

Character

Played By

Jacob Dutton

Harrison Ford

Cara Dutton

Helen Mirren

Spencer Dutton

Brandon Sklenar

Alexandra Dutton

Julia Schlaepfer

Elizabeth Strafford

Michelle Randolph

Banner Creighton

Jerome Flynn

Teonna Rainwater

Aminah Nieves

Jack Dutton

Darren Mann

Donald Whitfield

Timothy Dalton

Elsa Dutton (voiceover)

Isabel May

read more

Cara is undoubtedly one of the most interesting members of the Dutton family in 1923. Thanks in large part to Mirren’s captivating performance, Cara lights up the screen each time she appears. Even when the action of 1923 picks up as the series comes to a close, Cara is not left behind in the dust but rather gets into the heat of battle herself to fight for her family. Despite marrying into the family, Cara is a Dutton through and through, exhibiting all the traits one would come to expect from the fierce fighters. Taylor Sheridan and his team can’t afford to forget about a character as compelling as Cara, who could easily lead her own series if given the opportunity.

What Would Cara Dutton’s Spinoff Look Like?
There Are Numerous Possibilities for a Cara Spinoff
Cara Dutton played by Helen Mirren looks into the distance in 1923
Image via Paramount
Cara Dutton’s potential spinoff could take many different forms. Perhaps the most obvious storyline would follow Cara as a younger woman before the events of 1923. The series could follow her as she immigrates from Ireland and learns to assimilate into a very different country and culture. Jacob Dutton could also factor into a Cara Dutton spinoff, giving the Yellowstone franchise a chance to lay the groundwork for their relationship and marriage. Such a series would also break from the bonds of the Dutton ranch, which has been the setting of every Yellowstone series thus far, to explore different locations as Cara journeys from place to place before finally settling down in 1923.

The Yellowstone Franchise

Series

Years

IMDb Rating

Rotten Tomatoes Score

Streaming

Yellowstone

2018-2024

8.7/10

84%

Peacock

1883

2021-2022

8.7/10

89%

Paramount+

1923

2022-2025

8.3/10

90%

read more

John Dutton (Kevin Costner) is standing on a hilltop with a shovel held across his shoulders above the title for Yellowstone on the show’s poster.
Yellowstone
8

10

Release Date
2018 – 2024-00-00

Network
Paramount

Showrunner
Taylor Sheridan

Writers
Taylor Sheridan, John Linson

Franchise(s)
Yellowstone
instar53884447.jpg
Kevin Costner

instar37327245.jpg
Finn Little

Creator(s)
Taylor Sheridan, John Linson
Previous Chapter
Next Chapter

Related articles

Predicting Every Dutton Fate At The End Of Yellowstone

As the end of Yellowstone season 5, part 2 approaches, predictions can be made about where every Dutton will end up at the series’ conclusion. While it…

1923 Season 3: Everything We Know

This story contains spoilers for the 1923 season 2 finale. Before Spencer Dutton (Brandon Sklenar) finally made it back home, 1923 season 3 seemed inevitable. Then Taylor…

Will there be a 1923 season 3? Latest news on Yellowstone prequel

The status of the show remains a mystery, with the crew and studio staying coy on precisely what they have planned next for 1923 and the Yellowstone…

Yellowstone star Kelly Reilly moves on from Kevin Costner series in new detective drama

Yellowstone star Kelly Reilly has landed a role in a new crime thriller series following the conclusion of the Taylor Sheridan drama. Yellowstone actress Kelly Reilly, known…

The Latest Yellowstone Spinoff Might Be the Biggest One Yet

The “Yellowstone” franchise is getting a significant expansion with its latest spinoff centered on Luke Grimes’ character, Kayce Dutton. Following the conclusion of the flagship series on…

How ‘1923’ Paved the Path to Next ‘Yellowstone’ Prequel Series ‘1944’

How ‘1923’ Paved the Path to Next ‘Yellowstone’ Prequel Series ‘1944’ The next spinoff in the ‘Yellowstone’ prequel-verse jumps ahead to the ’40s, and could follow several…