Emmerdale is about to explode with a chilling new fan theory suggesting that John Sugden might be about to commit another murder! With Nate Robinson’s body finally discovered in the lake, a dangerous game of blame has begun, and many fear that Tracy Robinson could be John’s next victim as he desperately tries to cover his tracks.

Nate’s Body Found: The Aftermath

The discovery of Nate’s body in the lake has sent shockwaves through the village, particularly for Tracy and Cain Dingle, who are both plunged into a spiral of grief and regret. For Cain, the news hits hard, prompting immediate remorse for the bitter way he left things with his son. In a dramatic move, he admits to the police that he had a physical altercation with Nate shortly before his disappearance. Tracy, quick to reveal Cain’s actions, inadvertently puts him in the crosshairs. As Cain is questioned at the police station, he rapidly emerges as their prime suspect, fueled by his confession of beating Nate.

Meanwhile, Tracy herself begins to harbor chilling doubts, wondering if Cain, in the heat of their confrontation, could actually have been responsible for Nate’s death. Unbeknownst to them, the real killer, John Sugden, is far away on his honeymoon with Aaron, seemingly incommunicado. But his imminent return threatens to dredge up a fresh hell for everyone involved, especially now that Nate’s body has been found.

Is Tracy in Danger? A Chilling Fan Theory Emerges!

As the recent scenes aired, Emmerdale fans flocked to social media, speculating wildly about the direction of this explosive storyline. A terrifying new theory quickly gained traction: could John strike again, putting Tracy in grave peril?

“Theory: Jon kills Tracy. Franky goes to Kane and Moira,” one fan ominously wrote on Reddit, predicting a devastating outcome. Another user on X (formerly Twitter) shockingly declared, “Tracy is the most pointless character now. Hope Jon kills her next.”

The dark logic behind this theory is simple: with John desperate to cover his tracks, and now being an “in-law” to Cain through his marriage to Aaron, he might be keen to clear Cain’s name to divert suspicion. If Tracy becomes too close to the truth, or her own investigation threatens to expose him, she could easily wind up as “collateral damage” in John’s twisted game. The question looms large: Is Tracy in mortal danger?

John Targets Tracy: Police Investigation Intensifies!

Emmerdale spoilers for next week reveal that the fan theories might be disturbingly close to the mark, as John DOES indeed target Tracy! Keen to protect Cain – and, more importantly, protect himself by redirecting suspicion – John sets a cunning plan into motion. Before long, the police come knocking on Tracy’s door with a warrant in hand, ready to search her property.

Tracy confidently asserts that they’ll find nothing incriminating, but her composure shatters when detectives make a shocking discovery: Nate’s phone is found hidden in Frankie’s playhouse! This discovery immediately casts a dark shadow of suspicion over Tracy, and she is promptly taken down to the station for further questioning.

At the police station, Tracy’s panic escalates when investigators reveal a crucial detail: there is no record of the removal man who supposedly collected Nate’s belongings. This revelation unravels her alibi, pushing her into a desperate corner. Panicking, Tracy provides a full, desperate alibi, naming Vanessa Woodfield as the person she was with when Nate disappeared. But the tension remains palpable: will Vanessa back up Tracy’s version of events, or will Tracy find herself further entangled in the web of deceit surrounding Nate’s tragic death, pushing her closer to John’s dangerous machinations?

The Stakes Are Higher Than Ever!

With Nate’s killer finally confirmed as John, and Tracy now caught in the crosshairs of the police investigation, the stakes in Emmerdale have never been higher. Will Tracy become John’s next victim in his desperate attempt to conceal his monstrous crime? Or will she, armed with her own growing suspicions and the support of her loved ones, manage to expose the true villain before it’s too late?

The village is a powder keg of suspicion and fear, and as John Sugden returns from his honeymoon, a dark storm is brewing that threatens to engulf more innocent lives. Don’t miss these explosive episodes, where every secret threatens to unravel and every character is a potential target in John’s deadly game!

Who do YOU think is next on John’s hit list? Let us know your theories below!